Skip to content
Ryan James
Menu

← Blog10 min read

Hybrid Is Dead

To use some inspiration from Nietzsche, 'Hybrid Learning is dead. Hybrid Learning remains dead. And we have killed it.' We need to really take a step back from the past 12 months and reflect on what have we actually been doing as teachers with our students. If the answer is teaching and learning through Hybrid Learning, then that's just a lie that we've been telling ourselves. Let's dive in and see what this is all about.

Hybrid Is Dead

Let’s Be Honest

To use some inspiration from Nietzsche, ‘Hybrid Learning is dead. Hybrid Learning remains dead. And we have killed it.’ We need to really take a step back from the past 12 months and reflect on what have we actually been doing as teachers with our students. If the answer is teaching and learning through Hybrid Learning, then that’s just a lie that we’ve been telling ourselves. Let’s dive in and see what this is all about.

Hybrid Learning - An Explanation

With the pandemic doing its thing on America over the past 12 months we’ve been forced into partial school openings where due to lack of spaces, many teachers have been teaching part in person and part online. This is referred to as Hybrid Learning since some students are present in the classroom and some are learning from home using Zoom, Microsoft Teams, or Google Meet. This is a great idea in theory, we can keep the learning going and have students from home meet with us virtually and still create a feeling of the classroom we are used to having. Students at home can interact with the teacher and their classmates and as teachers we don’t lose any instructional days with the students who are learning from home.

Where did Hybrid Learning fall off the rails? Well, it was doomed from the beginning. Hybrid works best with students you already have relationships with. How do you establish norms and trust when you need that to start learning online? You can’t establish a norm for a student who doesn’t have technology at home or who doesn’t know to turn on cameras, mics, and speakers during class. Also, as a teacher, now you’re supposed to be an internet and tech guru while also being an expert in your content area and paying attention to the emotional well-being of each student. I understand that teachers are meant to handle a lot each day, but this is definitely crossing that line. It is almost impossible to interact with students in the room and students learning from home with the same amount of attention and energy. So what now?

Take Inspiration From Others

When you feel like you’re failing your students, do not keep doing what you’ve been doing. Do what I do and steal from other teachers. Rob Dominguez solved this problem earlier in the year. Rob is doing amazing things at Altamont in Birmingham, AL and you really should be reading his blog routinely. In his post on November 18th, he outlines what he calls the Tutoring Bar and how he uses this in his classes. So let me explain how that inspired me to recreate my classes starting in January.

In January, my school went full remote and I was not going to keep my students on Zoom all day long. We would all be so tired by the end of each day that we would not have any energy to do the extra things that teaching and learning requires. So, I created Modules for each of my lessons. In these modules was an ‘everything you need’ to learn a specific content standard. I would include notes, videos, a Google Form, and a mastery problem or problem set. This allows for students to work at their own pace and also not be on a video call where they are staring at multiple video feeds at once. Each day would be a new learning module and sometimes a learning module may just be practice with no videos or forms to complete. I wanted to get straight to the point of learning with no fluff. The video, notes, and forms were expected to take the student 30-40 minutes and then they would spend 15-20 minutes on the mastery problems. For a quick student this would be a 45 minute class and my students with time accommodations would spend 60-80 minutes on a learning module.

Results and Data

The question I get most, is how did students perform? The results were very good for my older students. I teach 9th - 12th grade students, so my younger or less mature older students required more guidance or reminders. With that being said, I had the opportunity to create the lesson how I wanted to in advance and spend my class time spending time one on one with students that needed help. It greatly reduced my tutorial appointments and email questions from students. When talking to students, the only thing they wished they had was 1 day a week to be where everyone learning online at the same time. When we moved back into a hybrid setting, I still maintained this learning model and students that needed more attention, they were given the option to listen in on a class lecture instead of watching videos. I still recommended for them to keep their cameras off to lower anxiety. My attendance was always checked back to the work they submitted. If a student submitted their work on time, they were marked present for the day.

Now that vaccines are rolling out, I’m hoping that we are nearing the end of all of this. I will continue using digital tools in the classroom, but hoping to skim back a little. I’m getting really tired of video conferencing on a daily basis. One thing I have learned is how much learning can take place even with reduced time constraints. If we focus on what students need and not what we think is fun as educators, students can do so much more.

Keep coding!
Ryan